So I finally redeemed the seven cards I had and I did pretty good. The newest card I got was an '85 Topps. I even got a couple vintage Reds cards, not too bad.
1) '52 Gerry Staley
2) '72 Rollie Fingers
3)'71 Reds Rookie Stars Frank Duffy and Milt Wilcox
4) 1961 Harry Anderson (Reds)
5) 1966 Tom Egan (Angels)
6) 1972 Mike Paul (Rangers)
7) 1985 Tito Landrum (Cardinals)
I saw on Ebay the redemption cards have almost doubled from about a dollar a piece to two on average.